Discussion about this post

User's avatar
D Bey's avatar

Good reading this. Your thoughts on "Sinners" embodying the deep history of Black music from ancient to future is spot on. I would differ though on Smoke and Stack being largely indistinguishable in character, beyond the surface difference that you mention. Ryan Googler does a deep dive into this in his interview on The Breakfast Club (which I've linked below). Do watch it if you haven't. I've thought about the sameness/difference issues with identical twins quite a bit over the years, prodded by two identical twin photographs, one by Diane Arbus the other by South African photographer Peter Magubane, as well as by my study of Yoruba Ibeji twin figures tradition, which appear identical, but always have subtle but distinct differences. My suspicion that Coogler had done serious study into the nature of identical twins in "Sinners" is confirmed in this interview. Suffice it to say the film bears watching twice with this in mind. You'll likely notice their differences more on second viewing. But these difference are distinctly noticeable when they act alone rather than when they are together. Check out Coogler on this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YWqTXowtqJg

Expand full comment

No posts